Universal Statistics of Competition in Democratic Elections
Ritam Pal, Aanjaneya Kumar, and M. S. Santhanam
Elections for public offices in democratic nations are large-scale examples of collective
decision-making.
As a complex system with a multitude of interactions among agents, we can anticipate that
universal macroscopic patterns could emerge
independent of microscopic details. Despite the availability of empirical election data,
such universality, valid at all scales,
countries, and elections, has not yet been observed. In this work, we propose a
parameter-free voting model and analytically show
that the distribution of the victory margin is driven by that of the voter turnout, and a
scaled measure depending on margin
and turnout leads to a robust universality. This is demonstrated using empirical election
data from 34 countries, spanning
multiple decades and electoral scales. The deviations from the model predictions and
universality indicate possible electoral malpractices.
We argue that this universality is a stylized fact indicating the competitive nature of
electoral outcomes.
Voter Turnouts Govern Key Electoral Statistics
Ritam Pal, Aanjaneya Kumar, and M. S. Santhanam
Elections, the cornerstone of democratic societies, are usually regarded as unpredictable
due to the complex interactions that shape them at different levels.
In this work, we show that voter turnouts contain crucial information that can be leveraged
to predict several key electoral statistics with remarkable accuracy.
Using the recently proposed random voting model, we analytically derive the scaled
distributions of votes secured by winners, runner-ups, and margins of victory,
and demonstrating their strong correlation with turnout distributions. By analyzing Indian
election data -- spanning multiple decades and electoral scales --
we validate these predictions empirically across all scales, from large parliamentary
constituencies to polling booths. Further, we uncover a surprising
scale-invariant behavior in the distributions of scaled margins of victory, a characteristic
signature of Indian elections.
Finally, we demonstrate a robust universality in the distribution of the scaled
margin-to-turnout ratios.
Indian General Elections 2024: A preliminary health-check on the electoral process
Ritam Pal, Aanjaneya Kumar, and M. S. Santhanam
Usually, election analysis for public consumption is focused on who the winner will be or if
there will be a change of incumbent.
On the date we prepared this article, the votes were yet to be counted, and we have limited
access to the turnout data in the general elections of 2024 (GE-2024).
Based on the available turnout data, in this article, we steer clear of predicting winner or
loser, but instead, we make predictions for the scaled margin distribution,
which is a potent indicator of electoral competitiveness. We employ RVM simulation in
conjunction with the turnout data of GE-2024 to derive this prediction.
We contrast this prediction with the historical Lok Sabha election data during 1999-2019. In
summary, this is like a preliminary health check on the mammoth election exercise that has
just concluded.
The physics and maths of keeping elections fair and representative
M. S. Santhanam, Aanjaneya Kumar, and Ritam Pal